Fagely made 12 appearances for the Golden Bears in 2012, charting a team-high seven wins and allowing only 47 hits on the season. His successful junior campaign came on the heels of a stellar sophomore campaign in which Fagely went 6-2 with 50 strikeouts.
Prior to CU: Fagely starred for Mahtomedi High School in hockey, football and baseball. He lettered in hockey three times and twice each in both football and baseball. Fagely was an All-Conference selection in 2008 in baseball.