Keenan made just three appearances for Vanderbilt as a freshman and did not surrender a run. The Tennessee Baseball Coaches Association voted Keenan to be First Team All-State as a senior. The Tennessee Sportswriters bestowed him with the same honor. Keenan earned 2009 District Pitcher of the Year as well as District Most Valuable Player. In 2006, he won District Freshman of the Year honors. Kolinsky posted great numbers on the football field as well. Kennan won the 2009 Wendy's High School Heisman for Christian Academy. He etched his name in the Christian Academy record books. He holds the school's record for rushing yards. Keenan also displayed strong leadership skills at Christian Academy. He was the Warriors captain in both baseball and football. His favorite athlete is LeBron James.