Henkemeyer spent the 2011 season with St. Cloud of the Northwoods League, where he batted .300 with 33 RBI and 15 SB. For his efforts Henkemeyer was named to the North Division All-Star team in 2011. With Minnesota in 2012 the outfielder played in 52 games and posted a .314 batting average.
Prior to the UofM- Henkemeyer was named to the All-Academic Big Ten team in 2011. As a student at Sauk Rapids-Rice, Henkemeyer was named to the Academic All-State team in 2009.